Law Offices of Scott D. Hughes
Request Your Free Consultation! 714.987.2671
  • Home
  • Attorney Profile
  • Criminal Defense
  • Case Results
  • Case Evaluation
  • Contact Us
  • Call Today
  • Email Us
  • Our Map
  • Menu
Blog 2010 October Prosecutor's "Golden Rule" and victim impact arguments required reversal of murder conviction.
Previous Post  |  Next Post

Prosecutor's "Golden Rule" and victim impact arguments required reversal of murder conviction.

Posted By Scott Hughes || 12-Oct-2010

In People v. Vance  (Cal.App. 1 Dist.) the prosecutor in a murder trial committed prosecutorial misconduct by making an improper "Golden Rule" argument inviting the jury to put itself in the victim's position, as well as improper victim impact arguments about the effect of the crime on the victim's family, and casting aspersions on defense counsel for objecting.

The prosecutor asked the jury to "walk" in the victim's shoes and to "literally relive in your mind's eye and in your feelings" what the victim experienced on the night he was killed in order to "get a sense of what he went through," and the prosecutor went beyond the evidence in narrating the victim's feelings and thoughts as he lost consciousness.

Although the trial court sustained some of the defense objections to the argument, the trial court's failure to take further action to curb the misconduct, such as by admonishing the jury, resulted in prejudicial error requiring reversal. The only contested issue was the defendant's intent, and the evidence that he had the requisite intent for first degree murder was not overwhelming.

Share Post

Contact the Law Offices of Scott D. Hughes!

Defend Your Rights. Safeguard Your Future.

Send My Information
  • Home
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
Law Offices of Scott D. Hughes

Call Today (714) 987-2671

Law Offices of Scott D. Hughes - Newport Beach Criminal Defense Attorney
620 Newport Center Drive, Suite 1100, Newport Beach, CA 92660 View Map
Toll-Free (714) 987-2671
Website: http://www.newportbeachcriminallaw.com/
© 2023 All Rights Reserved.
Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.